Taste at 55 | Latest UK & Wales Food & Drink News

Customer loyalty schemes – are they worth it?

Jack-new-image

Rising costs are eating into going-out budgets, with Barclays reporting a 6.7% decrease in restaurant spend in 2023. Indeed, the cost-of-living crisis has hit hard for both consumers and business owners, with accountancy firm, Price Bailey, reporting five daily shutdowns and 1,932 insolvencies last year alone.

Leveraging loyalty
Loyalty schemes can be a good way of bringing financially conscious customers back through the door, encouraging an otherwise tight-belt market to come in and support business. But does the custom gained through such methods truly offset the costs invested into giving away services? Or do cafés, bars and restaurants end up out of pocket, spending more on distributing discounts than the profits gained as a result?

Ultimately, it depends on the extent of the reward offered. The price-cut or freebie needs to be valuable enough to motivate people to want it, perceiving it as something worthy of regular custom – but not so valuable that the provider ends up in a financial mess. Overly generous offers only serve to devalue the rest of your products and services, anyway, with customers assuming that if you’re giving it away for free, it can’t be worth that much. It’s vital to strike the right balance.

Copying Costa
The Costa coffee ten-bean scheme, where people get a free drink once they have purchased ten, is a good example of this. Lured in by the promise of an attractive yet attainable reward, people are much more likely to purchase drinks from the chain on regular basis, with reduced likelihood of them straying to the competition. This regular custom more than offsets the cost of the free drink to Costa, with the reward remaining accessible enough that people won’t be put off by the amount they need to spend to reach it.

As the first to launch a points-based loyalty system back in 2010, Costa has since gained six million loyal customers, attributing one third of its sales to those signed up to the scheme, according to official company numbers. It just goes to show that loyalty is not just about revenue from direct sales, but also upselling, retaining customers and keeping them coming back for more.

Leading examples
Of course, the rewards granted needn’t be monetary – as clearly illustrated by Nando’s. The chain gives out staged rewards at specific increments in the customer journey, ensuring that customers keep coming back, without sacrificing revenue. The incentive for repeat visits doesn’t even have to loyalty based, provided that customers feel they are receiving value. Back in the day, for instance, Prêt employees could grant free surprise items at their will, helping to build a high-value, hospitality ethos that encouraged customers back through the door. The key is to determine which kind of rewards system is right for your business then leverage this scheme to your advantage.

Loyalty matters
Successful loyalty schemes maximise your customer base, whilst building your brand. They also help you to retain already valued clients, which is much more affordable than attracting new ones consistently through things like ad-based marketing.

Perhaps more importantly, however, loyalty schemes make customers feel like they matter, with small tokens of appreciation creating a lasting bond with your restaurant or service. This is particularly true when the offers available can be tailored to individual preferences for a more personal touch, based on things like historical purchase data. And herein lies the real question. Is a hand-held, physical stamp card enough to reap the rewards from loyalty customers in 2024? Or should companies be looking at more sophisticated, data-driven rewards systems, despite the increased initial cost?

App-based rewards
Whilst business size, turnover and available budget will inevitably have a bearing on end decisions, generally speaking, app-based and web-based loyalty schemes, that require users to create a login for sign-up, perform very well. As such, provided that a company is in a position to consider the investment, this is an option that should very much be put on the table.

The insights gained on customer wants and expectations can be used to drive better customer experiences, ramping up trust and satisfaction. Happier customers inevitably share positive reviews, whether on social media or via word of mouth, potentially providing an additional boost for business. Surveys and other interactive features can also be shared around to capture direct feedback, increasing the sense that customers are valued while tailoring future menus and products in accordance.

Of course, additional offers beyond the main loyalty scheme can also be introduced in an app, encouraging additional purchases that customers may not otherwise consider, potentially resulting in impromptu restaurant visits. Think of it as an opportunity for upselling, with that additional 15% being enough to make customers consider desert or add another dish to their usual choice.

The idea that these offers are limited to those in the know makes them seem even more valuable, with app-based schemes allowing restaurants to develop exclusive communications systems. Researchers have, in fact, found that such types of promotion can change the way people think and feel, with neuroeconomics professor, Dr. Paul J. Zak, claiming that using these discounts releases happy hormone, oxytocin – more so than a direct gift.

An undeniable win
Even when restaurants opt for a much simpler rewards-based system, without an initial digital launch, the effects could be life-changing, saving an industry from sinking by putting restaurant visits back on the menu for all kinds of visitors, whether they’re hungry for a bargain or simply appreciate thanks for their custom.

Jack Lander, Founder and Director of Pizzarova,

Exit mobile version