Zoe v Zoe: The Great Seed Oil Punch Up
Written by Harry Turnbull
Forget Tyson Fury v Anthony Joshua—this is the showdown captivating the world of diet and nutrition. In one corner stands South Wales’ Zoe Harcombe, a prominent obesity researcher advocating a nutritious unprocessed diet. In the other, the Zoe app team, led by scientists Tim Spector and Sarah Berry, champions of gut health and personalized nutrition.
At the heart of their clash? Seed oils.
Oils like rapeseed and sunflower have become a lightning rod in the nutrition world. Critics, including Harcombe and figures like Robert F. Kennedy Jr., argue that these oils are linked to inflammation, cancer, and other health issues. Meanwhile, the Zoe app team dismisses these claims as misleading, emphasizing the benefits of polyunsaturated fats and essential fatty acids.
The debate intensified when the Zoe team released a video mocking seed oil opponents with Professor Berry exclaiming their ‘misinformation drives her insane’ and that she looks forward to an inbox full of ‘hate mail’.
This prompted Ms Harcombe to fire back citing research on their potential harms. Both sides delve deep into the science, discussing omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids, but the public is left wondering: who’s right?
For Harcombe, the answer is clear: avoid seed oils and prioritize whole foods like butter and quality proteins. The Zoe app team, however, argues that seed oils can be part of a healthy diet when consumed in moderation and as part of a balanced approach to nutrition.
One of the main arguments appears to be that seed oils, when heated in a frying pan or in deep fat fryers, are prone to oxidation at high temperatures and this is bad for the body. Prof Berry asserts this is not correct and has done research work on the issue.
Zoe Harcombe dug out the research paper and discovered a test of blood vessel dilation involved 19 patients eating muffins with fresh oil and then with muffins with oil use to fry chips multiple times. There was no adverse affect, hence the claim oxidation does not occur. But Ms Harcombe pointed out inflammation can take years to impact the body not a few hours so such a trial had little value.
Ms Harcombe has a PhD in public health nutrition while Zoe is a multi-million pounds business that advises customers on diet after doing a simple test to determine their microbiome, the bacteria in intestines.
The truth, as often in nutrition, is nuanced. Industrial seed oils used in fast food and processed snacks may indeed pose health risks, but cold-pressed, high-quality varieties like British rapeseed oil are a different story. As someone who regularly uses the latter, I’m not ready to give it up—but I’ll certainly think twice about the highly processed alternatives.
In the end, the seed oil debate underscores a broader truth: nutrition is rarely black and white. Perhaps the real takeaway is to focus on quality, moderation, and individualized choices—whether you’re Team Harcombe or Team Zoe.
About the author
Harry Turnbull is an experienced journalist based in the north who has held a variety of reporting and editing roles in the media. As well as a regular guest contributor to the Need to See IT News titles, Harry also writes a reviews column for the UK’s biggest archive of BBC radio dramas.