All costs and no benefits: another blow for the hospitality sector as new red tape looms

Untitled-design-57

The hospitality sector, already facing a perfect storm of rising staff and food costs, increasing business rates, and energy price volatility, is warning that a proposed indoor vaping ban will add further pressure.

Under the Government proposal, vaping would be banned in most indoor public spaces, including cafes, pubs and clubs. Operators have questioned whether the additional costs can be justified, given the impact assessment identifies no clear public health or economic benefits.

The government is being urged to pause the proposal until clear evidence of public health benefits is provided.

Proprietor of London’s Hippodrome labels ban “an unreasonable enforcement burden”

Venues can currently set their own vaping policies, but the new proposal would make compliance a legal duty requiring new signage, staff training, active enforcement, all of which costs money. Operators may also be fined if customers breach the rules. The Government’s impact assessment estimates the costs to businesses could be in the region of £532 million.

High-profile business owners like Simon Thomas, owner of London’s iconic Hippodrome Casino are taking to social media to make their voices heard. 

“Most venues already manage vaping sensibly themselves and our customers are perfectly happy with the current position,” he says. “What changes with a national ban is that it turns something that venues currently handle as a house policy into a legal liability. If someone vapes discreetly in a busy bar or casino, suddenly the owner is the one who can be fined, which puts an unreasonable enforcement burden on hospitality businesses.”

All costs and no benefits?

While the health risks of secondhand smoke underpinned the smoking ban in hospitality venues, current evidence to date does not show comparable harm from ‘secondhand vaping’. In fact, studies suggest that everyday exposures such as roadside pollution, gas cooking, and frying can have a greater impact on air quality than vaping.

Dr. Marina Murphy, Senior Director, Scientific Affairs at Haypp Group describes why the proposal is flawed:

“There is no clear scientific basis for a ban. The evidence does not show harm to bystanders from secondhand vapour. Indoor air quality is more impacted by scented candles or open kitchens than by vaping. Good policy should target harm, not behaviours that do no harm to others. This measure will impose real costs on businesses and consumers with no measurable health gains.”

Regulation for the sake of regulation

The impact assessment itself acknowledges “substantial compliance and enforcement costs” with no quantifiable public health or economic benefits, with enforcement and the associated costs expected to fall on an already stretched businesses.

Dr Murphy added: “Previous public health advice has been that there is no evidence of harm to bystanders from exposure to e-cigarette vapour, and this has not changed. With hospitality already under pressure, regulation should only proceed where there are clear, demonstrable health benefits.”

What do you feel about this?